Michael Hay - Recovering Stutterer. That’s me. Or is it? Is there more to me than that? Am I a stutterer who happens to be other things, or am I somebody who just happens to have a stutter? Am I limiting myself by calling myself that or is it healthy to be facing up to my speech issue and being positive about my desire to become a better speaker?
People are labelled all the time. We are constantly having to define ourselves in polls or job applications by ticking boxes that represent who we are. These are then used to help organisations and governments with stats and numbers. It makes it easier for them. But it generalises us. It pigeonholes unique individuals into categories. If you are a stuttering, Welsh, conservative doctor what do you call yourself first and foremost? Are you a stutterer first? Does that affect everything else? Or are you a doctor first and foremost? Or c) all of the above?
If you label yourself can that be limiting? Can it be self perpetuating? If you label yourself stupid you may never think you can go for that degree. If you say “I’ve got a terrible memory” will you ever be able to remember things or will you just fall back into that comfortable label and not make the effort?
Alcholics Anonymous members label themselves as Recovering Alcoholics. This is to address their problem, take ownership and be positive. Is it the same with stammerers? Admitting you have a problem with your speech is crucial if you want to become a better speaker. You must be honest with yourself and others if you want to be able to address it fully and move on. I call myself a Recovering Stutterer because I feel that is a good way to communicate my situation plus I feel it is a positive way to express it. I could call myself an Improving Speaker, a Eloquent Trainee, a Person Who is Working on Their Speech. To me it doesn’t really matter. To me all that is important is that I am not hiding from my situation. I am facing up to the challenge before me.
Do I want to call myself a Recovering Stutterer all my life? That’s an interesting argument. I could say I will never be ashamed of the problem I have had as it has made me who I am. It could also be argued, however, that if I keep calling myself this then I will always be thinking about it and I will never be able to break free from my past and move on. Maybe one day I will call myself a Recovered Stutterer. Maybe I will call myself an Eloquent Speaker. Or maybe I’ll call just call myself Michael.
Is labelling good? Is it honest? Does it hold you back? My personal view is that I think it simply depends on the attitude with which you do it. It can be used as a way to hide or it can be used as a way to address challenges.
Thoughts?